The problem that I have with the W3C's decision (assuming that I understand it correctly) is that at least in my opinion the value of the web goes way beyond supporting manual web browsing and enjoying digital media assets. I think that the web should evolve into a ubiquitous decision support system - this needs software agents that can help you no matter who's computer you may be using, what type of small device (phone, web pad) you may be using, etc. In this context, decision support means help in making dozens of decisions each day. User specific information filters, search agents, and personalized information repositories will require machine readable data with well defined semantics.
One approach is to have content management systems like Drupal and Plone publish information in parallel, both:
- HTML5 web pages for human consumption
- RDF/RDFS/RDFS+/OWL for consumption by software agents
My vision of the web is an increasing amount of data and information that we need customizable software agents or interfaces to cull out just what an individual user needs.
HTML5 needs a well designed notation for embedding extensible semantic information that does not rely on XML's extensibility.